Younger residents drawn to the region by agricultural and tech-sector jobs often expect a modern worship sound, while longtime community families cherish hymn-based services. Is updating worship style wise contextualization or a compromise of sacred tradition?
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentActually Isaac Watts wrote most of the classic hymns specifically to modernize worship and upset the traditionalists of HIS day so. Yeah. Every generation has this exact argument and somehow the church survives.
Born and raised in Boardman. My grandma sang Great Is Thy Faithfulness in that little church on Main Street every Sunday for 40 years. You want to swap that out for some laser-light-show chorus with four chords and the word 'amazing' repeated seventeen times? Hard pass.
False dichotomy. Our church in Boardman does BOTH and has for six years. We open with two contemporary songs, include one traditional hymn mid-service, and close with a classic doxology. Younger families stay. Older families stay. Problem solved. Why are we still debating this like it's 2003?
I'll tell you what's actually driving young families away and it's NOT the music. It's 90-minute services with no childcare and parking lots that flood every time it rains. Fix those first and then lets talk about worship style.
The real issue nobody wants to say out loud is that some of these churches arent primarily asking 'what honors God' theyre asking 'what fills seats.' And when filling seats becomes the main metric you have already lost something essential about what worship is supposed to be. I'm not against contemporary music per se but I am against churches that treat Sunday morning like a product launch.
Contextualization is literally what Paul describes in 1 Corinthians 9:22 — becoming all things to all people. If contemporary music reaches a 28-year-old irrigation tech worker who would never walk into a hymn-only service, that is not compromise. That is mission. Boardman is growing fast and our churches need to decide whether they want to grow with it or become museums.
Contemporary praise music was written by committees to produce emotional responses. Most of it has zero theological depth. Compare the doctrine packed into 'A Mighty Fortress Is Our God' versus literally any Hillsong track and tell me with a straight face we should be trading down. We are starving people spiritually and calling it growth.
I used to attend a church in Hermiston that went full contemporary almost overnight. Within two years they lost about a third of their longtime members, mostly elderly folks who felt completely displaced in their own congregation. Those people mattered too. You cant just write off the people who kept the lights on for decades.
ok so i just moved here from the Portland area for a job at the potato processing plant and honestly the first sunday i walked into a local church and heard organ music i almost walked back out lol. not saying its bad just... wasnt what i grew up with. i stayed though and actually some of those old hymns hit different once you learn the words
my kids (7 and 9) actually asked me why the songs at church are so slow and why nobody claps. kids notice. just saying.
Question for any Boardman locals here: which specific churches have already made the switch and which are still traditional? Asking because my family is relocating from Boise this summer for an ag management position and we're trying to find a church home before we even get there. DM me if you know the landscape.
Should Christians pray to saints — or is asking Mary and the dead for help straight-up idolatry?
56 comments
Did Christianity give birth to modern science — or did the church spend centuries trying to strangle it in the cradle?
56 comments
Do humans have an immortal soul — or did the church steal that idea from Plato and dress it up as Scripture?
55 comments
Does God choose who gets saved, or do you choose God — and is Calvinism secretly making God into a monster?
55 comments